To Enter Without Disappearing Ambivalence, Value, and Continuity in the Modern Jewish Self
Research Article
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.58372/2835-6276.1425Keywords:
assimilation, emancipation, Haskalah, Ostjuden, Jewish continuity, shadow, Vienna, hermeneuticsAbstract
The modern Jewish encounter with European civilization is usually narrated as a contest between fidelity and betrayal, with assimilation cast as moral failure and continuity as moral achievement. This essay argues that the framing is wrong, and that its wrongness has consequences we are still paying for. Drawing on Jacob Katz, Arthur Hertzberg, Zygmunt Bauman, Steven Aschheim, Shulamit Volkov, David Sorkin, Todd Endelman, Michael Herzfeld, and Jonathan and Daniel Boyarin, I reconstruct assimilation not as a defect of loyalty but as a structurally induced ambivalence: the predictable psychological residue of an emancipation contract whose terms were never fully written down.
I then press a second question that the historiography tends to leave unasked. Granting that Jewish continuity is desirable, what makes it desirable? PostHolocaust survivalism answered by making continuity self-justifying, and in doing so risked handing the antisemite authorship of Jewish identity.
Contemporary “continuity” discourse inherited that structure and largely secularized it into demography. I argue instead for a value-first account: a tradition earns transmission by the quality of attention it forms in those who receive it, and Jewish continuity is worth wanting because the interpretive discipline it produces is worth having — a claim I test against my own clinical hermeneutics.
The essay closes with the Soloveitchikian figure of ger ve-toshav, stranger and resident, read not as a problem awaiting resolution but as the permanent structure of a mature modern Jewish self, and with the Jungian and Neumannian claim that the visibly traditional Jew and the acculturated Jew function as each other’s shadow rather than as each other’s refutation.
References
Bauman Z. Modernity and Ambivalence. Cambridge: Polity Press; 1991.
Bauman Z. Exit visas and entry tickets: paradoxes of Jewish assimilation. Telos. 1988;(77):45–77.
Fackenheim EL. God’s Presence in History: Jewish Affirmations and Philosophical Reflections. New York: New York University Press; 1970.
Katz J. Out of the Ghetto: The Social Background of Jewish Emancipation, 1770–1870. Cambridge (MA): Harvard University Press; 1973.
Hertzberg A. The French Enlightenment and the Jews: The Origins of Modern Anti-Semitism. New York: Columbia University Press; 1968.
Boyarin D, Boyarin J. Diaspora: generation and the ground of Jewish identity. Critical Inquiry. 1993;19(4):693–725.
Sacks J. Will We Have Jewish Grandchildren? Jewish Continuity and How to Achieve It. London: Vallentine Mitchell; 1994.
Ungar-Sargon J. Hermeneutic approaches to medicine: from objective evidence to patient as sacred text. EC Neurology. 2025;17(6):1–10.
Gordon MM. Assimilation in American Life: The Role of Race, Religion, and National Origins. New York: Oxford University Press; 1964.
Endelman TM. Leaving the Jewish Fold: Conversion and Radical Assimilation in Modern Jewish History. Princeton: Princeton University Press; 2015.
Volkov S. The dynamics of dissimilation: Ostjuden and German Jews. In: Reinharz J, Schatzberg W, editors. The Jewish Response to German Culture: From the Enlightenment to the Second World War. Hanover (NH): University Press of New England; 1985. p. 195–211.
Herzfeld M. Cultural Intimacy: Social Poetics in the Nation-State. 2nd ed. New York: Routledge; 2005.
Sandmel S. Parallelomania. Journal of Biblical Literature. 1962;81(1):1–13.
Stanislawski M. Autobiographical Jews: Essays in Jewish Self-Fashioning. Seattle: University of Washington Press; 2004.
Katz J. Tradition and Crisis: Jewish Society at the End of the Middle Ages. Cooperman BD, translator. New York: Schocken Books; 1993.
Baron SW. Ghetto and emancipation: shall we revise the traditional view? Menorah Journal. 1928;14(6):515–526.
Rosman M. How Jewish Is Jewish History? Oxford: Littman Library of Jewish Civilization; 2007.
Feiner S. The Jewish Enlightenment. Naor C, translator. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press; 2004.
Litvak O. Haskalah: The Romantic Movement in Judaism. New Brunswick (NJ): Rutgers University Press; 2012.
Bartal I. The Jews of Eastern Europe, 1772–1881. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press; 2005.
Sorkin D. Jewish Emancipation: A History Across Five Centuries. Princeton: Princeton University Press; 2019.
Katz J. The term “Jewish emancipation”: its origin and historical impact. In: Altmann A, editor. Studies in Nineteenth-Century Jewish Intellectual History. Cambridge (MA): Harvard University Press; 1964. p. 1–25.
Mendes-Flohr P, Reinharz J, editors. The Jew in the Modern World: A Documentary History. 3rd ed. New York: Oxford University Press; 2011.
Hess JM. Germans, Jews and the Claims of Modernity. New Haven: Yale University Press; 2002.
Mendelssohn M. Jerusalem, or On Religious Power and Judaism. Arkush A, translator. Hanover (NH): University Press of New England; 1983.
Sorkin D. Moses Mendelssohn and the Religious Enlightenment. Berkeley: University of California Press; 1996.
Batnitzky L. How Judaism Became a Religion: An Introduction to Modern Jewish Thought. Princeton: Princeton University Press; 2011.
Arendt H. The Jew as pariah: a hidden tradition. Jewish Social Studies. 1944;6(2):99–122.
Arendt H. Rahel Varnhagen: The Life of a Jewess. Winston C, Winston R, translators. London: East and West Library; 1958.
Mosse GL. German Jews Beyond Judaism. Bloomington: Indiana University Press; 1985.
Sorkin D. The Transformation of German Jewry, 1780–1840. New York: Oxford University Press; 1987.
Kaplan MA. The Making of the Jewish Middle Class: Women, Family, and Identity in Imperial Germany. New York: Oxford University Press; 1991.
Meyer MA. The Origins of the Modern Jew: Jewish Identity and European Culture in Germany, 1749–1824. Detroit: Wayne State University Press; 1967.
Slezkine Y. The Jewish Century. Princeton: Princeton University Press; 2004.
Gay P. Freud, Jews and Other Germans: Masters and Victims in Modernist Culture. New York: Oxford University Press; 1978.
Yerushalmi YH. Freud’s Moses: Judaism Terminable and Interminable. New Haven: Yale University Press; 1991.
Ungar-Sargon J. Divine instruments: Bach’s Partitas, mystical theodicy, and the suffering physician. Journal of Religion and Theology. 2025;7(4):80–94.
Ungar-Sargon J. “My heart tells me”: “and my heart tells me” — Rashi’s intuitive hermeneutic and the epistemology of clinical intuition. Journal of Psychiatric Insight Review. 2025;1(4):1– 11.
Meyer MA. Response to Modernity: A History of the Reform Movement in Judaism. New York: Oxford University Press; 1988.
Silber MK. The emergence of ultra-Orthodoxy: the invention of a tradition. In: Wertheimer J, editor. The Uses of Tradition: Jewish Continuity in the Modern Era. New York: Jewish Theological Seminary of America; 1992. p. 23–84.
Samet M. The beginnings of Orthodoxy. Modern Judaism. 1988;8(3):249–269.
Katz J. A House Divided: Orthodoxy and Schism in Nineteenth-Century Central European Jewry. Brody Z, translator. Hanover (NH): Brandeis University Press; 1998.
Katz J. Divine Law in Human Hands: Case Studies in Halakhic Flexibility. Jerusalem: Magnes Press; 1998.
Breuer M. Modernity Within Tradition: The Social History of Orthodox Jewry in Imperial Germany. Rosenbluth E, translator. New York: Columbia University Press; 1992.
Hirsch SR. The Nineteen Letters of Ben Uziel. Drachman B, translator. New York: Funk & Wagnalls; 1899.
Berger PL. The Heretical Imperative: Contemporary Possibilities of Religious Affirmation. Garden City (NY): Anchor Press/Doubleday; 1979.
Taylor C. A Secular Age. Cambridge (MA): Belknap Press of Harvard University Press; 2007.
Soloveitchik H. Rupture and reconstruction: the transformation of contemporary Orthodoxy. Tradition. 1994;28(4):64–130.
Ungar-Sargon J. History, scripture, and the challenge of modernity: comparing the Netziv, Reb Zadok, and Ramchal. Journal of Religion and Theology. 2025;7(4):45–63.
Heilman SC. Sliding to the Right: The Contest for the Future of American Jewish Orthodoxy. Berkeley: University of California Press; 2006.
Rosman M. Founder of Hasidism: A Quest for the Historical Ba’al Shem Tov. Berkeley: University of California Press; 1996.
Biale D, Assaf D, Brown B, Gellman U, Heilman S, Rosman M, et al. Hasidism: A New History. Princeton: Princeton University Press; 2018.
Wodziński M. Hasidism: Key Questions. New York: Oxford University Press; 2018.
Neumann E. The Roots of Jewish Consciousness. Vols 1–2. Lammers AC, editor; Lammers AC, Kyburz M, translators. London: Routledge; 2019.
Liebscher M, editor. Analytical Psychology in Exile: The Correspondence of C. G. Jung and Erich Neumann. Princeton: Princeton University Press; 2015.
Neumann E. Depth Psychology and a New Ethic. Rolfe E, translator. London: Hodder and Stoughton; 1969.
Ungar-Sargon J. Neither object nor abyss: relational theology from Hasidism to the Twelve Steps to the bedside. American Journal of Medical and Clinical Research & Reviews. 2026;5(1):1–15.
Fader A. Mitzvah Girls: Bringing Up the Next Generation of Hasidic Jews in Brooklyn. Princeton: Princeton University Press; 2009.
Ungar-Sargon J. The sacred paradox of healing: integrating shadow and light in medicine, politics, and spirituality through Jungian and Kabbalistic wisdom. Journal of Psychology and Neuroscience. 2025;7(3):1–16.
Aschheim SE. Brothers and Strangers: The East European Jew in German and German Jewish Consciousness, 1800–1923. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press; 1982.
Gilman SL. Jewish Self-Hatred: Anti-Semitism and the Hidden Language of the Jews. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press; 1986.
Lessing T. Der jüdische Selbsthaß. Berlin: Jüdischer Verlag; 1930.
Lewin K. Self-hatred among Jews. Contemporary Jewish Record. 1941;4(3):219–232.
Funkenstein A. The dialectics of assimilation. Jewish Social Studies. 1995;1(2):1–14.
Goffman E. Stigma: Notes on the Management of Spoiled Identity. Englewood Cliffs (NJ): Prentice-Hall; 1963.
Yoshino K. Covering: The Hidden Assault on Our Civil Rights. New York: Random House; 2006.
Bhabha HK. Of mimicry and man: the ambivalence of colonial discourse. October. 1984;28:125– 133.
Fanon F. Black Skin, White Masks. Markmann CL, translator. New York: Grove Press; 1967.
Ungar-Sargon JY. Fraternal rupture and somatic pathology: the Joseph narrative as clinical paradigm for family and communal conflict. Advance Medical & Clinical Research. 2025;6(2):238–242.
Schorske CE. Fin-de-Siècle Vienna: Politics and Culture. New York: Alfred A. Knopf; 1980.
Beller S. Vienna and the Jews, 1867–1938: A Cultural History. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 1989.
Rozenblit MI. The Jews of Vienna, 1867–1914: Assimilation and Identity. Albany: State University of New York Press; 1983.
Wistrich RS. The Jews of Vienna in the Age of Franz Joseph. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 1989.
Le Rider J. Modernity and Crises of Identity: Culture and Society in Fin-de-Siècle Vienna. Morris R, translator. New York: Continuum; 1993.
Bettauer H. Die Stadt ohne Juden: Ein Roman von übermorgen. Vienna: Gloriette-Verlag; 1922.
Rozenblit MI. Reconstructing a National Identity: The Jews of Habsburg Austria During World War I. New York: Oxford University Press; 2001.
Ungar-Sargon J. The wound as altar: an anti-theodicy of the Shoah. Journal of Religion and Theology. 2026;8(2):6–28.
Frankel J. Prophecy and Politics: Socialism, Nationalism, and the Russian Jews, 1862–1917. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 1981.
Jacobs J. Bundist Counterculture in Interwar Poland. Syracuse (NY): Syracuse University Press; 2009.
Fishman DE. The Rise of Modern Yiddish Culture. Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press; 2005.
Shimoni G. The Zionist Ideology. Hanover (NH): Brandeis University Press; 1995.
Ahad Ha’am. Slavery in freedom. In: Selected Essays of Ahad Ha’am. Simon L, translator. Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society of America; 1912. p. 171–194.
Zipperstein SJ. Elusive Prophet: Ahad Ha’am and the Origins of Zionism. Berkeley: University of California Press; 1993.
Raz-Krakotzkin A. Exile within sovereignty: toward a critique of the “negation of exile” in Israeli culture [Hebrew]. Teoria u-Vikoret. 1993;4:23–55 and 1994;5:113–132.
Luz E. Parallels Meet: Religion and Nationalism in the Early Zionist Movement (1882–1904). Schramm LJ, translator. Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society; 1988.
Schwartz D. Religious Zionism: History and Ideology. Stein B, translator. Boston: Academic Studies Press; 2009.
Boyarin D, Boyarin J. Powers of Diaspora: Two Essays on the Relevance of Jewish Culture. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press; 2002.
Boyarin J. Storm from Paradise: The Politics of Jewish Memory. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press; 1992.
Boyarin J. Thinking in Jewish. Chicago: University of Chicago Press; 1996.
Boyarin J. Polish Jews in Paris: The Ethnography of Memory. Bloomington: Indiana University Press; 1991.
Boyarin D. Unheroic Conduct: The Rise of Heterosexuality and the Invention of the Jewish Man. Berkeley: University of California Press; 1997.
Hilberg R. The Destruction of the European Jews. 3rd ed. New Haven: Yale University Press; 2003.
Friedländer S. Nazi Germany and the Jews: The Years of Persecution, 1933–1939. New York: HarperCollins; 1997.
Volkov S. Germans, Jews, and Antisemites: Trials in Emancipation. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 2006.
Volkov S. Antisemitism as a cultural code: reflections on the history and historiography of antisemitism in Imperial Germany. Leo Baeck Institute Year Book. 1978;23(1):25–46.
Jung CG. Wotan. In: Civilization in Transition. Collected Works, vol. 10. Hull RFC, translator. 2nd ed. Princeton: Princeton University Press; 1970. p. 179–193.
Ungar-Sargon J. The covering of blood from Sinai to the crematoria on a silent thread and the twentieth-century inversion of the covered ground. Journal of Religion and Theology. 2026;8(2):28–46.
Ungar-Sargon J. Between divine judgment and divine absence: post-Holocaust theology in the dialectic of Midas HaDin and Midas HaRachamim. Journal of Religion and Theology. 2025;7(1):40–49.
Fackenheim EL. To Mend the World: Foundations of Post-Holocaust Jewish Thought. New York: Schocken Books; 1982.
Wyschogrod M. Faith and the Holocaust. Judaism. 1971;20(3):286–294.
Woocher JS. Sacred Survival: The Civil Religion of American Jews. Bloomington: Indiana University Press; 1986.
Neusner J. Stranger at Home: “The Holocaust,” Zionism, and American Judaism. Chicago: University of Chicago Press; 1981.
Ungar-Sargon J. Revelation in concealment: toward an embodied post-Holocaust spirituality. Journal of Religion and Theology. 2025;7(3):1–23.
Ungar-Sargon J. Radical rupture: Chabad’s theological continuity when divine withdrawal precedes sin. Journal of Religion and Theology. 2025;7(3):35–48.
Cohen SM, Eisen AM. The Jew Within: Self, Family, and Community in America. Bloomington: Indiana University Press; 2000.
Berman LC. Speaking of Jews: Rabbis, Intellectuals, and the Creation of an American Public Identity. Berkeley: University of California Press; 2009.
Pianko N. Jewish Peoplehood: An American Innovation. New Brunswick (NJ): Rutgers University Press; 2015.
Magid S. American Post-Judaism: Identity and Renewal in a Postethnic Society. Bloomington: Indiana University Press; 2013.
Kravel-Tovi M. When the State Winks: The Performance of Jewish Conversion in Israel. New York: Columbia University Press; 2017.
Sacks J. One People? Tradition, Modernity, and Jewish Unity. London: Littman Library of Jewish Civilization; 1993.
Endelman TM. Radical Assimilation in English Jewish History, 1656–1945. Bloomington: Indiana University Press; 1990.
Ungar J. The agony of the yarmulke. Judaism. 1985 Aug.
Yerushalmi YH. Zakhor: Jewish History and Jewish Memory. Seattle: University of Washington Press; 1982.
Biale D. Not in the Heavens: The Tradition of Jewish Secular Thought. Princeton: Princeton University Press; 2011.
MacIntyre A. After Virtue: A Study in Moral Theory. 3rd ed. Notre Dame (IN): University of Notre Dame Press; 2007.
Ungar-Sargon J. A religious response to Harari: the secular versus mystical interpretation of Jewish history. Advance Medical & Clinical Research. 2025;6(2):185–193.
Ungar-Sargon J. The patient as parable: highlighting the interpretive framework: applying mystic hermeneutics to patient narratives. The International Medical Journal. 2025;25(2):41–50.
Ungar-Sargon J. Erotic discipline and halakhic mastery: reconceptualizing the am ha’aretz and the talmid chacham in contemporary discourse. Advanced Educational Research & Reviews. 2025;2(1):60–64.
Soloveitchik JB. Confrontation. Tradition. 1964;6(2):5–29.
Soloveitchik JB. The lonely man of faith. Tradition. 1965;7(2):5–67.
Ungar-Sargon J. The lonely man of faith at sixty: dialectic, evolution, critiques, and an embodied resistance. Journal of Religion and Theology. 2025;7(4):95–105.
Rosenzweig F. The Star of Redemption. Hallo WW, translator. Notre Dame (IN): University of Notre Dame Press; 1985.
Glatzer NN. Franz Rosenzweig: His Life and Thought. 2nd ed. New York: Schocken Books; 1961.
Levinas E. Difficult Freedom: Essays on Judaism. Hand S, translator. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press; 1990.
Mendes-Flohr P. German Jews: A Dual Identity. New Haven: Yale University Press; 1999.
Ungar-Sargon J. Between the waters: umbilicus mundi on living tethered to the provisional. Journal of Religion and Theology. 2026;8(1):40–57.
Ungar-Sargon J. Makom, tzimtzum, and the collapse of the horse-and-rider parable/mashal. American Journal of Medical and Clinical Research & Reviews. 2026;5(6):1–23.
Jung CG. Aion: Researches into the Phenomenology of the Self. Collected Works, vol. 9ii. Hull RFC, translator. 2nd ed. Princeton: Princeton University Press; 1969.
Ungar-Sargon J. The shared abyss: trauma, responsibility, and the space between mutual wounding and the ethics of reconciliation between perpetrator and victim. Advance Medical and Clinical Research. 2025;6(2):194–205.
Erikson EH. Identity: Youth and Crisis. New York: W. W. Norton; 1968.
Ungar-Sargon J. Revelation in strange clothes: heresy as deferred prophecy in Orthodox Jewish thought. Journal of Religion and Theology. 2025;7(2):25–35.
Buber M. I and Thou. Kaufmann W, translator. New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons; 1970.
Hertzberg A, Hirt-Manheimer A. Jews: The Essence and Character of a People. San Francisco: HarperSanFrancisco; 1998.
Wisse RR. The Modern Jewish Canon: A Journey Through Language and Culture. New York: Free Press; 2000.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2026 American Journal of Medical and Clinical Research & Reviews
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
The journal is licensed under a 